How To Sell Sports Cards: 13 Places To Sell Your Cards

If you aren’t interested in your vintage cards or want more space for cooler collections, now is the chance the sell your sports cards online for good money.

People are always looking to grow their collections, and it doesn’t hurt you to sell something you don’t really want anymore!

We started flea market flipping a while ago, and it has opened our eyes to the world of collectibles, and it’s never too early or late to sell sports cards.

Learn our essential steps to sell cards and explore the top 13 platforms for turning your collectible cards into cash.

Key Takeaways

Don’t forget to research your cards’ value – you don’t want to sell yourself short!
Check out recent sales, price guides, and all that good stuff.
Choosing where to sell your vintage sports cards is super important – you want to pick a reliable place with a good customer base to sell cards.
Making money flipping sports cards can be pretty rewarding, so take a deep breath, follow these steps, and you’ll be raking in cash in no time – you’ve got this!

3 Ways For How To Sell Sports Cards

1. Pick Cards You Want To Sell Vs. Keep

The first step for selling is to take a moment and pick which cards you want to sell and which ones you’d rather keep.

I know it can be tough to make these decisions, especially when you’ve spent so much time and effort building your collection.

One way to think about this is to consider the baseball cards that hold a special place in your heart or have significant potential to increase in value.

Maybe it’s vintage sports cards of your favorite player or a limited edition card that’s hard to come by – these are the ones you might want to hang on to.

2. Research The Cards For Value

Imagine selling vintage baseball cards for a few dollars because you didn’t research their true value- and then finding out a few were worth $20+ each.

You lose out on a lot of money if you don’t research pricing online!

You can check out recent sales of similar cards on sites like eBay or other sports card marketplaces to get an idea of what people pay for cards like yours.

Then, you can also consult price guides, such as Beckett, which can help you get a ballpark figure for your card’s value.

Remember, the card’s condition, rarity, player popularity, and manufacturer all play a role in determining baseball cards’ worth, so keep those factors in mind.

3. Choose Where To Sell Sports Cards

Now comes the next big step: deciding where to sell your cards.

Start by considering the platform’s reputation, user base, fees, and ease of use. 

You want to pick a place known for its reliability, has a good audience of potential buyers, and won’t make you jump through hoops to list your cards. 

We’ve put together a list of the top 13 places where you can showcase your collection and attract eager buyers, so let’s get into it!

13 Best Places To Sell Sports Cards

1. eBay

So, you’ve probably heard of eBay, right? I mean, who hasn’t?

It’s like the OG of online marketplaces, and let me tell you, it’s still a fantastic place to sell your sports cards, flea market finds, and other collectibles. 

With a massive user base and tons of sports card enthusiasts browsing the site, you’re sure to find interested buyers eager to snag your prized collectibles.

Plus, with eBay’s auction-style listings, you could get even more for your cards than you initially expected – hello, bidding wars! 

2. Dave & Adam’s

Dave & Adam’s is a cool online store specializing in all sorts of collectibles, like sports cards and gaming cards.  

Basically, you fill out a form on their website with some info about your cards, and they’ll give you a quote for what you’re selling. 

If you’re happy with the offer, send them your cards, and they’ll pay you by cash, PayPal, and check.

It’s super easy and saves you a lot of time and effort if you want to skip bidding and are worried about buyers not coming through.

3. TonyeTrade

Let me tell you about another easy place to sell your sports cards – TonyeTrade. 

Tony has been in the sports card business for over 30 years and has built a solid reputation for buying and selling high-end sports cards and memorabilia. 

You just visit the website, shoot them an email with the details of the cards you want to sell, and they’ll get back to you with an offer. 

If you accept the offer, send the cards to them and get paid.

4. Kruk Cards

Kruk Cards is a well-established company that’s also been in the sports card and collectibles game for over 30 years. 

They’re known for buying and selling a wide range of cards, from vintage to modern, so there’s a good chance they’ll be interested in what you’ve got regardless of how old they are.

Kruk Cards buys a lot of things related to sports collectibles:

unopened wax boxes and cases
complete sets
key rookie cards (like Mantle, Unitas, etc.)
key singles and inserts (anything that books above $30)
key autographed and memorabilia pieces
a ballpark number of commons per sport, if applicable

5. COMC

COMC, short for Check Out My Collectibles, is like a one-stop shop for buying, selling, and trading sports cards and other collectibles.

What’s nice about this platform is that you can quickly create an account and list your cards for your price within minutes.

Plus, with a dedicated user base of collectors, you’ll find interested buyers for your vintage sports collections.

You’ll get store credit for your sales, but you can convert the credit into cash easily.

6. Facebook Marketplace

Facebook Marketplace is an excellent option to meet local buyers, avoid shipping hassles and fees, and connect with local sports card collectors.

It’s a super popular platform where you can buy and sell all sorts of items, including sports cards, with people in your local area.

No fees are involved, so you get to keep all the profits from your selling price!

7. Beckett

Beckett is the go-to resource for card pricing and grading vintage cards and modern cards, but did you know they also have an online marketplace where you can sell baseball cards online?

The Beckett Marketplace connects fellow card collectors and enthusiasts looking to buy sports cards online. 

Since Beckett is a well-known and reputable dealer in the sports world, you can trust them to sell vintage baseball cards and trading cards.

8. Offerup

Another online marketplace for selling your sports cards is OfferUp. It’s a mobile app and website where people can buy and sell various items locally, including sports cards.

OfferUp is super easy to use, and there are no transaction fees for basic listings to sell sports cards online, which means more money in your pocket!

You can meet up (safely!) and locally with buyers to sell baseball cards for fast sales, but you can do shipping if you’re more comfortable that way.

9. StockX

StockX is another interesting place to sell your sports cards. You might be familiar with them for their sneaker marketplace, but they’ve also expanded to include sports cards. 

It operates like a stock market, with buyers and sellers placing bids on cards, ultimately agreeing on a price when a bid and ask match up. 

The platform charges a seller fee, but the unique buying and selling experience, coupled with the authentication process, can make it an appealing option for selling sports cards online.

10. Otia

One of the best things about Otia is that they’re interested in buying your entire collection in bulk, saving you time and effort listing your cards online. 

That’s pretty cool, right? It can save you a ton of time and effort, especially if you have a large collection and need help selling it all. 

It’s a super convenient way to sell your sports cards, especially if you want to unload a big collection in one go.

11. PSA Card Forums

The PSA Card Forums are especially popular among people who are into graded cards, which is perfect if you’ve got some high-quality cards in your collection.

You can also browse the PSA card forums to see what baseball cards and sports memorabilia other collectors are looking for – and who knows, you might have just the card to sell them! 

Just remember that, like any online forum, it’s important to be cautious and use good judgment when dealing with potential buyers for your valuable cards.

12. Conventions

If you have a large collection of sports cards and maybe some other collectibles and are interested in selling your cards in person, you should check out local conventions.

Conventions make an excellent venue for selling your trading cards since you’ll be among fellow enthusiasts who share the same passion for collecting sports cards as you do.

Be prepared to pay a fee for your space, but it varies based on the convention’s size- from $50+ is typical. Just decide how much you’re willing to pay for a table and cap it!

13. Pawn Shops

While pawn shops may not be the first place that comes to mind to sell sports cards, they can be a good option if you’re looking for a quick sale and some fast cash.

Look up the value of your cards online or consult a price guide, so you have a good idea of what they’re worth before you walk in the door.

Bring your cards to a few pawn shops to compare offers and see who will give you the best deal before you settle on a sale.

You can also compare what they offer with sites like TonyeTrade, Dave & Adam’s, or Kruk Cards, where they send you offers for your cards.

FAQS

Why should I sell my sports cards?

Selling your card collection can put some extra cash in your pocket that you can use for anything you like – maybe even to invest in more cards or a new collection!

Not to mention, selling sports cards frees up space for your life, so you can use the space how you want.

How long should I hold out on selling sports cards?

That’s a tough question to answer since how much you’ll earn now or later depends on many factors.

The value of sports cards can fluctuate over time, depending on factors like player performance, rarity, and market trends.

It’s a bit like playing the stock market – it’s best to sell when values are high, but it might be worth holding onto your cards in hopes that their value will increase even more.

What sports cards are worth the most money?

Generally, cards featuring iconic players, rookie cards, and rare or limited edition cards fetch the highest prices.

For example, think of cards like the 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle, the 1986 Fleer Michael Jordan rookie card or the T206 Honus Wagner – these are all incredibly valuable and sought-after cards.

What site is best for selling sports cards?

The answer depends on what you’re looking for in a selling platform.

For instance, eBay is popular for selling cards online because it has a massive user base and offers much flexibility when listing your cards.

On the other hand, you might prefer a more specialized platform like COMC or Otia, which focus specifically on sports cards and collectibles.

Should I cross-post my cards for sale?

Cross-posting your cards can be a smart strategy because it increases the chances of finding a buyer and exposes your cards to a wider audience. 

The listing costs are the main drawback of listing on some sites. Remember that fees and shipping costs can vary across platforms, so factor that in when you sell sports cards. 

Be aware that some platforms may have rules against cross-posting, so always double-check their terms and conditions before you start. 

Lastly, make sure you can manage all the listings and buyer messages and keep the posts updated – you don’t want to sell the same card twice accidentally! 

Other Stuff To Sell Online

In addition to sports cards, you can sell more online to make extra cash.

Let’s explore some other popular things you can sell besides sports cards!

Your Words!

Selling sports cards isn’t the only way to make money online – have you ever considered using your interests?

Yep, I’m talking about blogging about your hobbies and pastimes! 

Blogging is a fantastic way to share your thoughts and experiences on a particular topic or niche – you could even start a blog about sports card collecting!

Learn more about starting a blog in our Start Your Blog Boot Camp and see how we went from side hustling to full-time blogging for more money than our 9-5s.

Other Skills

You can make money writing online and use your other skills to freelance for more money as a side hustle or career.

Becoming a freelancer can open many doors, even if you’re a beginner!

There are so many opportunities for people to make money on Steady, whether you’re a graphic designer, a programmer, a social media guru, or anything in between. 

Steady connects you with various gig opportunities, from freelance work to part-time jobs, so you can find the perfect fit for your skillset and schedule.  

Books

Selling books is a pretty easy way to make some extra cash, especially if you’re a book lover with a collection starting to take over your living space.

Whether you’ve got a bunch of used books you no longer want, or you’ve come across some gems at garage sales or thrift stores, selling books online can be a fun and profitable venture.

There are several platforms where you can get quotes for your books in seconds, such as sellbackyourBook.com.

Shoes

Did you know that selling shoes online can be a pretty lucrative business? Yeah, it’s true!

Whether you’re a sneakerhead with a closet full of kicks or stumbled upon some great deals at outlet stores, there’s a whole market of people looking for new and gently used shoes to add to their collection.

You can sell shoes online on several platforms, like eBay, Facebook Marketplace, Mercari, or Poshmark.

Furniture

Whether you’re looking to declutter your home or have a knack for refurbishing old pieces, there’s a huge market for selling furniture online.

You can check out Flea Market Flipping and learn how to find cool stuff at thrift stores and sell the on eBay for a profit!

Our Thoughts

We’ve covered quite a bit for selling sports cards and other items online.

I hope this has given you some ideas and inspiration to explore the world of online selling, whether for valuable sports cards, books, shoes, or furniture.

With so many platforms and opportunities available, there’s never been a better time to turn your collectibles or skills into a profitable side hustle or even a full-time business.

Who knows, you might find that selling online becomes a fun and rewarding part of your life!